What Is an Old Mine Cut Diamond?

• Origins & Time Period
  The Old Mine Cut dates back to the early 18th through the late 19th centuries—most popular during the Georgian (1714-1837) and Victorian (1837-1901) erase. Diamonds were hand-cut by artisans using less precise tools, often in candlelight, which shaped their distinctive look.
• Shape & Faceting
  These diamonds tend to be squarish (or cushion-like) with rounded corners. They have large, chunky facets, a high crown, a smaller table, and a large culet (the bottom point), which is often visible. These features give them more depth and a warm, romantic glow rather than the razor-sharp brilliance of modern cuts.
• Uniqueness & Imperfection
  No two Old Mine Cuts are exactly alike. Because of the hand-cut nature, you'll find asymmetry in shape, faceting, and proportion. Rather than being seen as flaws, these tiny irregularities are part of their charm.

• Old Mine Cut vs Old European Cut
  While both are antique styles, the Old Mine Cut is squarish with rounded edges and visible large facets, whereas Old European Cuts are rounder and somewhat more symmetrical. The culet in Old Mine Cuts tends to be larger and more visible. 
• Old Mine Cut vs Cushion & Modern Cuts
  Cushions are considered the modern cousin of Old Mine Cuts: they share shape but are more standardized. Modern brilliant cuts (round and other shapes) aim for maximum sparkle under artificial light, but Old Mine Cuts prioritize character, fire, and atmosphere.

1. Celebrity Influence

   A big spike in interest came after Taylor Swift revealed her engagement ring featuring an Old Mine Cut (lab-grown) diamond. This has been dubbed the “Taylor Effect,” sending search volumes for “Old Mine Cut” through the roof.
2. Authenticity & Story
   More people are seeking meaningful jewelry over mass-produced styles. Old Mine Cuts carry historical legacy, craftsmanship, and character. Their imperfections and warmth tell a story.
3. Lab-Grown Options
   Vintage cuts in lab-grown diamonds are becoming more available, which allows folks to get the Old Mine Cut look at more affordable prices with ethical sourcing.
4. Warmth Over Brightness
   The aesthetic taste is shifting—people are preferring warm glow, candlelight-style fire, and the softer shine of antique cuts rather than the ultra-bright glare of modern brilliant cuts.
5. Trend Toward Vintage & Personal
   Vintage-inspired jewelry with personal twist is big this year: custom designs, heirloom styles, mixed metals, and individuality over cookie-cutter perfection. Old Mine Cuts fit right into this movement.

• Examine the Shape: Aim for a length-to-width ratio under ~1.1 to keep the shape pleasing and balanced. Squarish cushion-like shapes tend to be more desirable.
• Inspect the Facets & Culet: Because of larger facets and visible culets, make sure they aren’t causing dark shadows or imbalanced light. A proper balance keeps it beautiful.
• Color & Clarity: Warmer diamond colors (G, H, I, maybe even J-K in some cases) often enhance the vintage vibe. Since facets are larger, inclusions and color are more easily seen. Choose clarity and color that look good to the eye.
• Setting Matters: Old Mine Cuts also pair beautifully with yellow or rose gold, bezel settings, filigree and vintage-inspired mounts. These settings emphasize their history and softer glow.
• Certification & Jeweler Reputation: Since each Old Mine Cut is unique, work with jewelers experienced with antique cuts or custom work. If possible, get certification from labs like GIA or similar that describe cut, symmetry, etc. Even though antique cuts often don’t have the same technical grading precision, credible documentation helps.

• At Beverly’s Jewelry, we understand that choosing an Old Mine Cut diamond is as much about emotion and heritage as it is about sparkle. Here’s how we guide you:

  
  

  • Our designers can custom-set an Old Mine Cut in a setting you love: Yellow or rose gold, bezel or halo styles, filigree details—whichever matches your personality.
  • We help you inspect the piece in person (or via high-resolution photos/video) so you can see exactly how the light, facets, and culet perform.
  • We offer ethical sourcing documentation where available, and transparent pricing so you know what you’re paying for—heritage, craftsmanship, and unique character, not just size.

Conclusion