Groomsmen Gift Ideas That Won’t Get Left Behind

Let’s be honest: your groomsmen do a lot. From standing by your side on the big day to helping plan the bachelor party and calming your pre-wedding nerves, they deserve more than a generic bottle opener or a set of socks. So how do you say thanks with a gift they’ll actually love—and use?

The key is finding groomsmen gift ideas that blend style, function, and personality. Whether you’re planning a destination wedding in the Virgin Islands or a hometown celebration, here are the top picks that won’t get tossed in a drawer or forgotten at the hotel.

1. Engraved Watches

A timepiece is timeless—literally. A sleek watch with your groomsman’s initials or the wedding date engraved on the back is stylish, meaningful, and wearable beyond the ceremony. Bonus Tip: Choose different styles to match each groomsman’s vibe (leather strap for the classic guy, metal for the minimalist).

2. Personalized Travel Dopp Kits

If you’re having a destination wedding in places like St. Thomas, a monogrammed leather toiletry bag is both practical and elevated. It’s perfect for travel and feels luxurious without breaking the budget.

3. Island-Inspired Jewelry

Yes, jewelry isn’t just for brides! Consider minimalist men’s bracelets or rings made with local materials like leather, onyx, or even Caribbean larimar. For a real keepsake, Beverly’s Jewelry in St. Thomas offers options crafted just for island memories.

4. Custom Whiskey Glasses or Decanters

Does your crew love a good pour? Personalized barware like etched whiskey glasses or a custom decanter set is a classy way to toast your friendship long after the big day.

5. Stylish Sunglasses

Planning a beach or tropical wedding? High-quality sunglasses make a cool and useful gift. Add a personalized touch with engraved cases or initials subtly printed on the inside arm.

6. Tech Essentials

Portable chargers, sleek Bluetooth speakers, or custom wireless earbuds cases show you’re tuned into their lifestyle. Bonus points if they’re engraved or come in sleek packaging.

7. Custom Cufflinks or Tie Clips

Classic groomsmen gifts that still impress when customized. Go with initials, wedding coordinates, or an inside joke. These small but mighty accessories make the wedding outfit pop—and serve as a reminder of the celebration.

8. Local Rum or Spirits

If your wedding is in the Caribbean, nothing beats a bottle of local flavor. Gifting a premium bottle of island-made rum (like BBD Rum from St. Thomas) brings home a taste of paradise. Pair it with a handwritten thank-you note.

9. Adventure Experience Gifts

Instead of a physical gift, give your crew an experience: scuba diving, sailing, golfing, or ziplining. These create shared memories that go beyond the ceremony. Pro Tip: If you're in the Virgin Islands, book a half-day snorkeling tour or paddleboard session for the guys.

10. Luxury Pen or Journal

For the groomsman who’s always jotting things down, a high-end pen or leather journal (engraved, of course) is a thoughtful, useful gift. It’s a classy option for writers, planners, or anyone who appreciates good stationery.

Make It Personal

The best groomsmen gifts are tailored to the individual. Think about what each friend enjoys and choose accordingly. And don’t forget to include a personal note or toast to make the moment even more meaningful.

Where to Shop?

Looking for something unforgettable? Beverly’s Jewelry in St. Thomas offers customizable gifts, island-inspired men’s accessories, and fine jewelry perfect for honoring your wedding party. Whether it’s a sleek bracelet, a nautical pendant, or a keepsake gift box, they’ve got the sparkle your groomsmen deserve.

Your groomsmen have your back. Show your gratitude with gifts that reflect the effort, the friendship, and the memories you’ve made together. Whether it’s a custom watch, local rum, or a travel-ready accessory, choose something they’ll want to keep for years to come—not something they leave behind.